Tony's New York Pizza

Nestled along the quiet stretch of New York Avenue in DeLand, Tony’s New York Pizza unfolds like a welcoming neighborhood haven—a place where the rhythm slows just enough for you to breathe in the scent of freshly baked dough and mingling herbs. The space carries a familiar warmth, the kind that invites both regulars and first-timers to settle in without rush, and the hum of easy conversation drifts gently between tables.

There’s an unhurried joy about dining here, where the heart of New York’s pizza tradition meets the comfort of a local corner spot. Whether you’re drawn to a crispy slice of classic New York-style pizza or intrigued by the unique spin of their Calabrian or Bruschetta creations, each bite feels like a quiet celebration of ingredients handled with care. The garlic knots and rolls bring that added touch of homely satisfaction, perfect for sharing or savoring alone between conversations.

Beyond pizza, Tony’s resonates with a family-like vibe—plates of rich pasta, hearty calzones, and thoughtfully crafted salads appear alongside slices that promise to be both familiar and a bit surprising. It’s the kind of place where servers don’t just take orders but offer recommendations as if guiding a friend to their favorite corner of the menu, making each visit feel personal and effortless.

Evenings here tend to unfold at their own comfortable pace. You’re encouraged to linger over a cold drink, sharing stories, or simply soaking in the welcoming atmosphere that weaves together locals and travelers alike. It’s this blend of authenticity and heartfelt hospitality that turns a simple dinner into a genuine experience—a reminder that food is as much about human connection as it is about flavor.